On March 11, 2009, the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) issued a Class One Recall for Single and Triple Channel COLLEAGUE Volumetric Infusion Pumps. Baxter Healthcare Corporation manufactures these infusion pumps. This is not the first recall for Baxter’s infusion pumps; it is the 7th recall in the past FOUR years. The FDA has failed at its job to protect the public’s safety. The FDA is allowing this product to remain on the market after seven recalls!
Volumetric infusion pumps are a type of medical device. The pump delivers intravenous medicine and fluids to patients. The drugs and fluids are delivered to the patient in controlled doses through intravenous (the vein), intra-arterial (the heart) or an epidural (through the spine). However, Baxter’s infusion pumps are defective.
On January 23, 2009, Baxter sent an Urgent Device Correction Letter to its users of the infusion pumps. According to the letter from Baxter, there were failure codes in the pumps. This caused the pumps to stop infusing when delivering medication and fluids to patients. In addition, the letter warned of a possibility the pump would overheat. If the pump overheated, this could lead to smoke and fire. These delays or failures to infuse medicine can be deadly. Patients may experience serious injury or even death. That is what a Class One Recall means; it is the most serious recall the FDA can order. In ordering a Class One Recall, there is a “reasonable probability that use of the product will cause serious injury or death.” This most recent recall pertains to several model types: Mono 2M8151 and 2M8153, CX 2M8161 and 2M8163, and CXE 2M9161 and 2M9163.
What’s worse, the FDA has known about the problems with Baxter’s pumps for years. In July 2005, the FDA issued its first of seven recalls for Baxter Volumetric Infusion Pumps. The July 2005 recall involved a WORLD-WIDE recall of ALL models. The infusion pumps shut down while they were delivering medication to patients. As a result, the pump failure caused six serious injuries and three deaths. There were two more Class One recalls in September and December 2005. Not to mention, the THREE recalls in 2007. With the most recall, that makes seven recalls in less than four years.
Even knowing all of this information, the FDA waited nearly two months before issuing the current recall. Baxter sent the letter to customers on January 23rd, but it took the FDA until March 11th to issue a formal Class One Recall. Why did the FDA wait so long? People’s lives are at stake. Since 2005, Baxter has not sold the infusion pumps in the U.S. However, that does not mean pumps are not still being used. It is estimated that 200,000 pumps are currently in use in the United States, at hospitals and clinics. Patients are obviously still been affected these pumps. There have been at least 16 more deaths reported because of Baxter’s pumps, since the initial 2005 recall.
Why has the FDA not done more? The FDA needs to order hospitals to discontinue use of Baxter infusion pumps. Obviously Baxter will not do it. Even in their letter to users, Baxter did not mention recalling their pumps. Instead, Baxter advised users on how to replace their defective pumps. The FDA has failed the public by allowing seven recalls to occur. What more reasons does the FDA need to act? Seven recalls and nearly 20 deaths should be enough to make the FDA do its job.